» Premier League + 1. Division nur Premier League
 
# Player Team(s) M. goals Penalty Ø
1 Jimmy Greaves Chelsea FC
Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United
516 357 29 0.69
2 Dixie Dean Everton FC
362 310 7 0.86
3 Gordon Hodgson Leeds United
Liverpool FC
Aston Villa
455 287 13 0.63
4 Alan Shearer Southampton FC
Newcastle United
Blackburn Rovers
559 283 56 0.51
5 David Jack Bolton Wanderers
Arsenal FC
474 257 1 0.54
6 Charlie Buchan Sunderland AFC
Arsenal FC
482 256 0 0.53
7 Nat Lofthouse Bolton Wanderers
452 253 2 0.56
8 Joe Bradford Birmingham City
410 248 5 0.60
9 Hughie Gallacher Derby County
Chelsea FC
Newcastle United
Grimsby Town
355 246 7 0.69
10 Joe Smith Bolton Wanderers
416 244 12 0.59
11 George Brown Leeds United
Aston Villa
Huddersfield Town
363 240 4 0.66
12 George Camsell Middlesbrough FC
337 232 2 0.69
Ian Rush Leeds United
Newcastle United
Liverpool FC
515 232 2 0.45
14 David Herd Manchester United
Arsenal FC
Stoke City
412 223 0 0.54
15 Tony Cottee Leicester City
West Ham United
Everton FC
548 215 9 0.39
Billy Walker Aston Villa
478 215 3 0.45
17 Harry Kane * Tottenham Hotspur
Norwich City
320 213 33 0.67
18 Geoff Hurst West Ham United
Stoke City
520 211 16 0.41
19 Ronnie Allen West Bromwich Albion
415 210 18 0.51
20 Dave Halliday Sunderland AFC
Arsenal FC
Manchester City
257 209 0 0.81
21 Wayne Rooney Manchester United
Everton FC
491 208 23 0.42
22 Arthur Chandler Leicester City
309 204 0 0.66
Bobby Gurney Sunderland AFC
348 204 0 0.59
24 Harry Johnson Sheffield United
313 203 0 0.65
Vic Watson West Ham United
294 203 0 0.69
26 Denis Law Manchester United
Manchester City
376 201 8 0.53
27 Bobby Charlton Manchester United
606 198 8 0.33
Stan Mortensen Blackpool FC
317 198 5 0.62
29 George Elliott Middlesbrough FC
328 197 2 0.60
Bobby Smith Chelsea FC
Tottenham Hotspur
346 197 1 0.57
31 Peter Harris Portsmouth FC
468 194 3 0.41
32 Ray Charnley Blackpool FC
359 190 11 0.53
Dennis Viollet Manchester United
Stoke City
391 190 1 0.49
34 Andy Cole Manchester United
Newcastle United
Sunderland AFC
Arsenal FC
Blackburn Rovers
Fulham FC
Manchester City
Portsmouth FC
415 189 1 0.46
35 Tommy Thompson Newcastle United
Aston Villa
Preston North End
354 187 0 0.53
36 Jack Bowers Derby County
Leicester City
255 186 4 0.73
37 Sergio Agüero Manchester City
275 184 27 0.67
38 Ginger Richardson West Bromwich Albion
269 179 1 0.67
Teddy Sheringham Manchester United
Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United
Nottingham Forest
Portsmouth FC
Millwall FC
521 179 21 0.34
40 Lee Chapman Leeds United
Sunderland AFC
West Ham United
Arsenal FC
Ipswich Town
Nottingham Forest
Sheffield Wednesday
Stoke City
508 177 0 0.35
41 Tony Brown West Bromwich Albion
460 176 26 0.38
Thierry Henry Arsenal FC
258 176 22 0.68
Frank Lampard Chelsea FC
West Ham United
Manchester City
609 176 43 0.29
44 Derek Dougan Leicester City
Blackburn Rovers
Aston Villa
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Portsmouth FC
458 175 0 0.38
45 Jack Rowley Manchester United
356 173 5 0.49
46 Peter Dobing Blackburn Rovers
Manchester City
Stoke City
509 172 8 0.34
47 Jack Weddle Portsmouth FC
368 171 0 0.46
48 Les Ferdinand Newcastle United
Leicester City
Tottenham Hotspur
West Ham United
Bolton Wanderers
Queens Park Rangers
403 170 0 0.42
49 Trevor Ford Sunderland AFC
Aston Villa
Cardiff City
324 169 5 0.52
Bob Latchford Everton FC
Coventry City
Birmingham City
Swansea City
384 169 2 0.44
* Active player